Forming a specialty underwriter of homeowners’ insurance in coastal markets

The Narragansett Bay Insurance Company logo

Narragansett Bay Insurance Company (“NBIC”) is a leading specialty underwriter of homeowners’ insurance products and services in states along the Eastern seaboard. Originally recapitalized out of receivership in 2008, NBIC was backed by Newlight Partners in partnership with Pine Brook Road Partners as a de novo specialty underwriter of homeowners’ insurance in CAT-exposed markets. By 2017, NBIC had organically grown to nearly 200,000 policies and $320m in premium when it was sold to Heritage Insurance Company.

Investment Facts

You find out about partners in tough times. While working with Newlight through Hurricane Sandy, they proved their mettle as great partners - knowledgeable of the industry and levelheaded through tough times. They knew when to support me and when to push me.

NBIC’s CEO on Newlight’s support during challenging times.

Background and Newlight Value Add

Following losses from hurricane Katrina, Rita, and Wilma many insurers exited the CAT-exposed markets, and the homeowners’ market was experiencing a market dislocation in coastal areas. NBIC was formed as a specialized, regional homeowners’ insurance carrier focused on developing a core competency in selecting, managing, and properly reinsuring coastal risk.

Executive Recruiting & Alignment

Newlight played a critical role in recruiting key management to NBIC, including introducing the CEO to the NBIC opportunity in 2012. Newlight introduced experts in other functional areas as well, leading to enhanced reserving procedures, reinsurance purchasing processes, and risk monitoring functions.

Capital and Regulatory Support

Following hurricane Sandy, the Newlight team worked hand-in-hand with the management team to recapitalize the company and maintain regulators and ratings agencies support for the business.

Operational Assistance & Governance

Newlight was highly involved in supporting management with dashboard design and monitoring, reinsurance purchasing decisions, and capital management.

The Case Studies are not necessarily representative of all past or current Newlight portfolio companies but were selected to illustrate Newlight's management approach and are intended for potential portfolio company executives. Certain statements about Newlight made by portfolio company executives herein are intended to illustrate Newlight’s business relationship with such persons, including with respect to Newlight’s facilities as a business partner, rather than Newlight’s capabilities or expertise with respect to investment advisory services. Portfolio company executives were not compensated in connection with their participation, although they generally receive compensation and investment opportunities in connection with their portfolio company roles, and in certain cases are also owners of portfolio company securities and/or investors in Newlight-sponsored vehicles. Such compensation and investments subject participants to potential conflicts of interest in making the statements herein. Newlight does not make any representation or warranty as to the accuracy or completements of the information contained herein and it should not be assumed that investments made in the future will be comparable in quality of performance to the investments described herein. Past performance is not necessarily indicative of future results. See the “Case Studies” section of the Disclosures page for important information about these Case Studies.
View Case Studies